Skip to main content
Advertising

Asked and Answered

Asked and Answered: Nov. 19

The opinions found in Asked and Answered do not reflect the views of the Steelers organization.

Let's get to it:

DAVID BROOKS FROM INDIANAPOLIS, IN: What's the story with Michael Pittman Jr.? What are your thoughts on him becoming a big-time legitimate option for Aaron Rodgers in the last half of the season, which is why we snagged Pittman from the Colts. Big target, decent speed, great hands, can catch the ball in traffic. Aaron Rodgers needs a target he can trust. I thought Pittman was a can't miss.
ANSWER: Let me start with some news: yesterday the Steelers started the 21-day clock on Michael Pittman Jr., Roman Wilson, and Gennings Dunker, and they moved Max Hurleman from practice squad IR to the active practice squad. They now have 21 days to evaluate Pittman, Wilson, and Dunker, and then they either have to add them to the 53-man roster or leave them on IR for the remainder of the season.

Specifically about Pittman, at 6-foot-4, 223 pounds he has the kind of size Coach Mike McCarthy likes in receivers, and in 98 games over 7 seasons in Indianapolis, he had 492 catches for 5,343 yards (10.9 average) and 25 TDs. His receptions also produced 265 first downs. Pittman's issue has been availability. He has been injured and missed all but 3 games, which has been uncharacteristic for him because in his seasons with the Colts, he missed only 1 game because of injury.

Pittman sustained a groin injury during the night practice at Latrobe Stadium on Aug. 8, and was one of the veterans who didn't take a snap during the preseason. In the opener vs. Atlanta, Pittman was targeted 3 times and made 3 catches for 58 yards, including a long of 28. He played 59 offensive snaps in the opener, which was No. 2 among Steelers WRs in that game. During the next week of practice, before the trip to New England, Pittman injured his foot. He didn't play vs. Patriots, but he played the next 2 weeks vs. Cincinnati (2 catches for 16 yards), and the following Thursday night in Cleveland (2 catches for 15 yards). Then he re-injured his foot in practice the next week, was put on IR on the day before the game vs. the Colts, and he had been there ever since.

I don't know what to tell you about what Pittman might be able to contribute to this offense, or even when he will be back on the field with a chance to contribute. But at the time of the acquisition, it seemed as though the Steelers were getting a veteran WR with size and a history of being productive as a complementary player in an NFL offense. Maybe even better than that, he had missed only 1 game due to injury over 7 seasons. And they acquired him in a trade for nothing more than a third-day draft pick swap. I thought Pittman was going to be a quality addition, both on the field and in the locker room as another proven veteran presence on offense. But foot injuries can be very serious for players at positions where careers depend upon quick movement and change of direction skills.

GLENN McCULLOUGH FROM PITTSBURGH, PA: This being Aaron Rodgers' last year, there is going to be a new starting QB next season. Are either Drew Allar or Will Howard ahead of the other so far? Which of the two do you favor so far?
ANSWER: Neither Drew Allar nor Will Howard has taken a snap since the preseason finale, so it's impossible for one to be ahead of the other as far as 2027. And the candidates to become the starting QB in 2027 won't even all be known until next May, and then that's when the competition will begin. I choose not to add to the noise until then, at the earliest.

DERRICK TROTTER FROM EAST LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM: Why did we not use timeouts at the end of the game against the Bengals? There was a good chance to get another TD and give some reps to backups, albeit in garbage time. I fully understand the game was lost and everyone wanted to go home, but would point differential potentially have an impact as a tiebreaker at the end of the season?
ANSWER: You don't want to lose players to injury in the meaningless final seconds of a 20-point defeat. At the end of that game in Cincinnati, there was just as good a chance at players being injured as doing anything meaningful. As for having an impact on tiebreakers, I can never remember a situation where points scored, or points differential ever determined a playoff spot or a division title. Too far down the list.

ISRAEL PICKHOLTZ FROM ASHKELON, ISRAEL: There has been speculation about the game vs. the Houston Texans on Dec. 6 being flexed out of the Sunday night time slot in favor of Bears-Jaguars. When does that have to be decided?
ANSWER: Any chatter about that has not come from the NFL, and so whatever was said is speculating. According to the NFL's website: "For Sunday Night Football in Weeks 5-13 and for Monday Night Football in Weeks 12-17, the NFL will decide and announce no later than 12 days in advance of the game, which game will be played on Sunday night and which game will be played on Monday night." So counting backward, 12 days before Dec. 6 is Nov. 24. The NFL will decide by Nov. 24 which game will be played on Sunday night and which game will be played on Monday night.

CHARLES MURRAY FROM WEST CHESTER, PA: During training camp there was a lot of discussion about moving T.J. Watt around on defense, playing both edges and even sometimes as a stand-up position on the interior. In the Cincinnati game it appeared that he only lined up on the left edge? Why haven't they moved him around more.
ANSWER: I never understood why it seemed to be so important to move T.J. Watt around the defensive formation. The only thing that really matters is where to put Watt to allow him to be as effective and impactful as he can be. In every game he ever has played, the opposing offense had identified where Watt is. He was the Defensive Player of the Year, he led the NFL in sacks 3 times, and he did it playing one spot. Find ways to help him be most effective from the spot in which he's most comfortable. That's all that matters.

JOE ASHER FROM TAMPA, FL: Your response to Dennis Woods on Nov. 17 inspired a follow-up question. Is there a rule in the NFL that a team cannot retire more than 47 jerseys? Which team has the most jersey numbers retired?
ANSWER: Sometimes I wish the NFL would have a rule limiting the number of "retired jersey" questions to Asked and Answered, but I'll play along. I doubt the NFL ever considered the need for such a rule – limiting the number of retired jerseys to 47 per team – and I can't believe the league is considering that now. According to NBC Sports, the top 5 NFL teams in terms of retired jersey numbers are: Chicago Bears, New York Football Giants, San Francisco 49ers, Kansas City Chiefs, and Philadelphia Eagles.

SAM MIKHAIL FROM BETHESDA, MD: It seems Mason McCormick will be lost for the season. Spencer Anderson has frequently lined up as an extra or "jumbo" sixth offensive lineman. Will he now replace Mason or could someone else fill the position?
ANSWER: I have seen reports that Mason McCormick did not sustain any broken bones when he was injured in Cincinnati, and that as a result he will not require surgery. I wouldn't describe any of that as definitive at this point.

At this point in the process, I certainly imagine Spencer Anderson is at the top of the list to replace for McCormick. But as I mentioned in a previous answer here, the Steelers activated the 21-day clock on Gennings Dunker to return to practice this week. I'm not suggesting Dunker will be a starter at LG, but he was drafted to play guard.

GLENN JOHNSON FROM CARROLLTON, OH: Are there innovative defensive formations that could significantly confuse opposing offenses?
ANSWER: I think there might be more "innovative defensive formations" that could significantly confuse the players being asked to execute them in a game.

JAMES SMASAL FROM FORT WORTH, TX: Will Coach Mike McCarthy look at much film of the loss to the Bengals? Or will he chalk it up to whatever could go wrong, did go wrong in the game?
ANSWER: Without any first-hand knowledge of Mike McCarthy's process, I believe his coaching philosophy is way too detail-oriented to just chalk anything up. He often talks about things that happen in games as being teaching points, so I have no doubt there were flaws/mistakes identified in video study of the Bengals game and then discussed/practiced this week.

JOHN PASQUINELLI FROM WENDELL, NC: I am not much of a podcast person, but this year I began listening to Ben Roethlisberger's podcast. Do you listen to it and if so what do you think? I like it because it gives a player's perspective of the games and what they see. I like how much of a Steelers fan Ben and his family seem to be after his retirement.
ANSWER: I am not a podcast person at all, with the exception of the Asked and Answered podcast I do with Tom Opferman because it's part of my job. I have nothing against podcasts, nor against players doing podcasts and talking about the league, their former team, the direction of the sport, whatever. Speaking of Opferman, he does a podcast with Vince Williams from 10 a.m.-noon daily on SNR, "Steelers Blitz" and I can tell you that in interviewing Williams a couple of times during the previous couple of training camps, I found him someone who will tell you what he thinks.

KEN SEITZ FROM RICHMOND, VA: What is your opinion on having Jaylen Warren share carries with Rico Dowdle? On one hand, it'll help him rest and stay healthier as games progress, but on the other hand it may be limiting his potential for yards, TDs, and MVP votes. Also, do you think he has an opinion either way?
ANSWER: My impression of Jaylen Warren is that above all else, he wants to win. Certainly he has the confidence in himself to be a significant part of the team's ability to win, but he is way too savvy a professional to believe the national NFL media is going to vote for a RB to be the league's MVP when you have Joe Burrow and Josh Allen and Patrick Mahomes all putting up big numbers for contending teams. The NFL is a QB league. It's always about the QB.

Advertising